In Chapter XIV of Biographia Literaria, Coleridge makes a distinction between prose and poetry. He writes:
“The difference between poetry and prose appears to consist in this: that poetry is the best words in the best order. Prose is words in their best order; poetry is the best words in the best order.”
He further argues that:
“The same elements of language are used in both prose and poetry, but poetry differs in purpose, in imaginative vision, and in the emotional response it seeks to evoke.”
He emphasized that poetry and prose share the same linguistic components, but what distinguishes poetry is the selection, arrangement, and intentionality—particularly its aesthetic and emotional purpose.
The correct answer is 2. Samuel Taylor Coleridge, and here’s why:
Coleridge is known for his work in literary theory, particularly his thoughts on poetry and its relationship to prose. He argued that the fundamental elements of both poetry and prose are the same — language, words, and expression — but the distinction lies in how these elements are combined and what the purpose behind them is.
In his seminal work, Biographia Literaria (1817), Coleridge discussed this idea, distinguishing between poetry and prose not by their material elements but by the way those elements are used. He emphasized that poetry is shaped by different combinations of words, meter, and sound to evoke heightened emotional or aesthetic experiences, whereas prose focuses more on direct communication of ideas or information.
This philosophical distinction about form and purpose reflects Coleridge's deep engagement with the nature of creativity and imagination, setting his views apart from more traditional, rule-based understandings of poetry like those of Alexander Pope or John Dryden.
Thus, it is Coleridge who is credited with acknowledging that poetry and prose are built from the same linguistic elements but differ in their combination and purpose.